Provider Provisioned Virtual Private Networks WG (ppvpn) Wednesday, August 08 at 0900-1130 ================================== CHAIRS: Marco Carugi marco.carugi@francetelecom.com Rick Wilder richard_h_wilder@yahoo.com MAILING LIST: ppvpn@zephion.net (currently) ARCHIVES: //ppvpn.francetelecom.com NOTE : total time below is 2H45. Sorry for reduced individual time allocations (depending on number of SP service deployment feedbacks, some other time slots might be increased). Agenda bashing - chairs PPVPN work status (mailing list, goals/milestones, WG IDs, L2 space work, design teams, candidate solutions, missing work, related ITU-T progress) - 10 min - Marco Carugi PPVPN Service requirements update - 5 min - Dave McDysan draft-ietf-ppvpn-requirements-02.txt Changes from 00, open issues, future usage PPVPN Framework update - 5 min - Ross Callon/Muneyoshi Suzuki draft-ietf-ppvpn-framework-01.txt Changes from 00, open issues, future usage PPVPN CE-based Framework using IPsec - 10 min - Jeremy De Clercq draft-declercq-ppvpn-ce-based-00.txt (renamed as draft-ietf-ppvpn-ce-based-00.txt) Just ID overview, future steps, open issues L2 point-to-point VPN space (requirements, solutions): Discussion on open issues, solution convergence, WG IDs - 10 min - related ID authors/all Related IDs : draft-rosen-ppvpn-l2vpn-00.txt (renamed as draft-ietf-ppvpn-l2vpn-00.txt) draft-kompella-ppvpn-l2vpn-00.txt draft-martini-l2circuit-trans-mpls-06.txt draft-shah-mpls-l2vpn-ext-00.txt draft-shah-mpls-l2vpn-reduce-00.txt L2 Metro VPN space (requirements, solutions): - Report from design team activity - 20 min - design team members Related requirement and framework-oriented IDs (10 min from 20 above): draft-tsenevir-l2-req-01.txt draft-ouldbrahim-ethernet-l2vpn-requirements-00.txt draft-heron-ppvpn-vpsn-reqmts-00.txt draft-augustyn-vmi-m2m-arch-00.txt draft-senevirathne-vmi-frame-01.txt Relation with basic req and framework IDs to be discussed. Just overview of draft-augustyn-vmi-m2m-arch-00.txt to be given. Related solution-oriented IDs (10 min from 20 above): draft-lasserre-tls-mpls-00.txt draft-vkompella-ppvpn-vpsn-mpls-00.txt Just overview of both IDs to be given ; open issues, future steps and solution convergence to be discussed - Brief discussion : issues, missing work, solutions, WG IDs - 5 min - all L3 VPN space(requirements, solutions): BGP-MP for layer 2 VPN membership discovery draft-tsenevir-bgp-l2vpn-01.txt - 5 min - Tissa Senevirathne Just ID overview, open issues and future work, how to deal with Report on VPN MIB progress, issues, future steps - 5 min - Thomas Nadeau, Elwin Stelzer Related IDs : draft-nadeau-mpls-vpn-mib-04.txt draft-elwin-ppvpn-vr-mib-00.txt SP feedback from deployment of candidate solutions - 30 min max - some SPs (expected feedback on rfc2547bis, ouldbrahim-vpn-vr, rfc2917bis, CE-based IPsec) Slot under construction (Equant on rfc2547bis, ...) Applicability Statement guidelines - 5 min - Junichi Sumimoto Just overview of main concepts, open issues, possible future steps Related IDs: draft-sumimoto-ppvpn-applicability-guidelines-00.txt : not submitted (just sent to the list), available at http://ppvpn.francetelecom.com ->Related Internet drafts-> London Optical VPN requirements - 5 min - Hamid Ould-Brahim draft-ouldbrahim-ovpn-requirements-00.txt Just ID overview, why to be considered in PPVPN, future possible steps in OVPNs Discussion on PPVPN issues and future work topics - 30 min - chairs(/ADs/TA)/all - draft-rosen-vpns-ospf-bgp-mpls-02.txt OSPF issue - draft-rekhter-ppvpn-gre-ip-2547-00.txt (renamed as draft-ietf-ppvpn-gre-ip-2547-00.txt) encapsulations issue - Plan for requirements and framework progress - Choice of first set of candidate solutions for standard track, plan for second set - New WG IDs (L2 VPNs, ...) - Possible new work items (optical VPNs, tunnel topology, ...) - Solution-specific work - main deliverables per each solution, deliverable structure, protocol enhancement validation from other WGs, solution-specific teams ?, positioning against requirement and framework IDs - L2 point-to-point VPN space recap (issues, solutions, interaction w/PWE3) - L2 metro VPN recap (team work, issues, solutions) - Applicability Statement : deliverable structure and number, launch of solution/approach-specific AS work - Inter-AS VPN - requirement document (design team ?), organisation of solution-specific work, deliverables - Salt lake City : main objectives, intermediate work steps, work ready for the meeting Layer 3 VPNs using Encapsulation Services Protocol - 5 min - Nishit Vasavada draft-vasavada-ppvpn-es-l3vpn-00.txt Just ID overview, open issues, future steps, why should be considered, how to deal with VPN tunneling protocol draft-elwin-ppvpn-vtp-00.txt - 5 min - Elwin Stelzer Just ID overview, open issues, future steps, why should be considered, how to deal with Tunnel topology - 10 min - Tissa Senevirathne, Heinrich Hummel Related IDs : draft-tsenevir-l2vpn-pmesh-00.txt draft-hummel-ppvpn-tunnel-systems-01.txt Just : which PPVPN problems addressed, open issues, future steps, how to deal with Slot requests currently not allocated (just if time): BGP/MPLS VPN extension for IPv6 VPN over an IPv4 infrastructure draft-nguyen-bgp-ipv6-vpn-02.txt (renamed as draft-ietf-ppvpn-bgp-ipv6-vpn-00.txt) - Jeremy De Clercq Changes from previous version, open issues, future steps BGP/GMPLS solution for inter-domain optical networking draft-xu-bgp-gmpls-01.txt - Yangguang Xu Just ID overview, open issues, future steps, why relevant for PPVPN, how to deal with