I could only found nits in this I-D that shouldn't hold it from progressing: 0) Nits checker complains about the following line being to long in s5.3: mail.client.example CAA 0 issuemail "authority.example; account=123456" can you do this: mail.client.example CAA 0 issuemail "authority.example; account=123456" Link breaks added for formatting purposes. 1) s/must not/MUST NOT in s6: OLD: If a Certification Authority does not understand the Property, then it must not issue the certificate in question. NEW: If a Certification Authority does not understand the Property, then it MUST NOT issue the certificate in question.